EMILY PAYNE'S HORSE NEGLECT SCANDAL IN BANBURY: RSPCA RESCUE AND CONVICTION

In a distressing case of animal neglect, Emily Patricia Payne, also known as Emily Farmer, who resides at Manor Court in Banbury, has been found guilty of failing to properly care for two horses under her supervision. The incident drew significant attention from the RSPCA, which launched an investigation into the long-term neglect of the animals, leading to their rescue and subsequent veterinary assessments.

Payne’s neglect was particularly evident in the condition of a thoroughbred mare named Esp and a Welsh cross pony mare called Ruby. The RSPCA’s investigation revealed that both horses had been living in severely inadequate conditions, with their needs grossly unmet. Esp was found in a field near Brackley, with empty hay troughs and water buckets, indicating a lack of basic sustenance. The field itself was barren, offering minimal grass for grazing. Ruby, similarly, was found suffering from overgrown hooves and untreated laminitis, a painful condition caused by inflammation of the laminae within the hoof.

Following their rescue, Esp was examined by a specialist equine veterinarian who reported no clinical abnormalities aside from her extremely poor body condition. A clinical examination showed that Esp’s weight had increased from 454 kilograms on August 31 to 482 kilograms by September 12. The veterinarian explained that this rapid weight gain, achieved solely through dietary improvements, was indicative of a prolonged period of malnutrition, with Esp having been starved for several weeks prior to rescue.

Ruby’s condition was equally concerning. Radiographs taken during her veterinary assessment revealed overgrown hooves and rotation of the pedal bone, signs of chronic laminitis. The veterinarian concluded that Ruby’s suffering was due to inadequate hoof care and untreated pain, which should have been alleviated through remedial farriery. The neglect of her hoof health had led to significant discomfort and deterioration of her condition.

Inspector Susan Haywood of the RSPCA, who led the investigation, expressed her disappointment over the case. She stated, “Cases like this are very sad as they could so easily be avoided. We hope it is a reminder that caring for horses is a huge responsibility and highlights the importance of ensuring their welfare.” She further emphasized that the RSPCA offers advice and assistance to improve animal care standards, often giving owners time to rectify issues. However, despite these efforts and veterinary guidance, Payne continued to neglect her animals’ basic needs.

Since their rescue, both Esp and Ruby have been in the care of veterinary professionals and have shown signs of recovery. Nevertheless, the legal proceedings culminated in Payne’s conviction last month, despite her initial plea of not guilty. She was sentenced to 18 weeks in custody, suspended for 18 months, and ordered to pay a total of £1,115 in fines and costs. Additionally, she was disqualified from keeping any equines for a period of five years, a ban that will expire in August 2024.

This case serves as a stark reminder of the importance of responsible animal ownership and the severe consequences of neglecting the welfare of vulnerable animals in the Banbury area and beyond.