KAYSLEY SMITHEN'S TRAGIC FATAL ATTACK IN BIRMINGHAM'S SPRING HILL: A CASE OF MANSLAUGHTER AND MENTAL HEALTH STRUGGLES
| Red Rose Database
Birmingham Domestic Homicide
In a tragic and disturbing incident that unfolded in Birmingham, a young man has been convicted of manslaughter following the death of his mother, Janice Smithen. The incident occurred in the summer of 2012, specifically in July, within the residential area of Spring Hill, Hockley. The court proceedings revealed that Kaysley Smithen, who was 26 years old at the time of the trial, carried out a brutal assault on his mother, inflicting severe head injuries with a metal weights bar.
According to the evidence presented at Birmingham Crown Court, Smithen admitted to being responsible for her death but argued that he was suffering from insanity at the time of the attack. The court heard that the assault was particularly violent, with Mrs. Smithen sustaining serious trauma to her head, which ultimately led to her death. Police reports confirmed the severity of her injuries, indicating that she had been subjected to a brutal and fatal assault.
It was also disclosed during the trial that Smithen had a diagnosed mental health condition—paranoid schizophrenia—and had been detained under the Mental Health Act following his diagnosis. His family had sought medical help for him approximately 18 months prior to the tragic event, recognizing his deteriorating mental state. Despite being prescribed medication, Smithen frequently refused to take it, claiming that his mother was attempting to poison him. This refusal to adhere to treatment was a significant concern for his family and mental health professionals.
The court heard that if Smithen had been detained under the Mental Health Act earlier, his mother’s death might have been prevented. The case underscores the ongoing difficulties faced by mental health services in managing individuals with severe mental illnesses, especially when there are signs of potential violence within family settings. The tragic loss of Mrs. Smithen highlights the critical importance of timely intervention and effective mental health support to prevent such devastating outcomes in the future.
According to the evidence presented at Birmingham Crown Court, Smithen admitted to being responsible for her death but argued that he was suffering from insanity at the time of the attack. The court heard that the assault was particularly violent, with Mrs. Smithen sustaining serious trauma to her head, which ultimately led to her death. Police reports confirmed the severity of her injuries, indicating that she had been subjected to a brutal and fatal assault.
It was also disclosed during the trial that Smithen had a diagnosed mental health condition—paranoid schizophrenia—and had been detained under the Mental Health Act following his diagnosis. His family had sought medical help for him approximately 18 months prior to the tragic event, recognizing his deteriorating mental state. Despite being prescribed medication, Smithen frequently refused to take it, claiming that his mother was attempting to poison him. This refusal to adhere to treatment was a significant concern for his family and mental health professionals.
The court heard that if Smithen had been detained under the Mental Health Act earlier, his mother’s death might have been prevented. The case underscores the ongoing difficulties faced by mental health services in managing individuals with severe mental illnesses, especially when there are signs of potential violence within family settings. The tragic loss of Mrs. Smithen highlights the critical importance of timely intervention and effective mental health support to prevent such devastating outcomes in the future.